Casey Key, Florida Real Estate

Casey Key is a beautiful location offering tropical, oceanside properties overlooking serene beaches and crystal blue waters. This 7-mile long barrier island in the Gulf of Mexico is just off the South-West coast of Florida. The Southernmost point of Casey Key begins just North-West of the town of Venice, the Northernmost end connects to Siesta Key via Midnight Pass (which can only be traversed by foot!)., and the inner-waters between Casey Key and the mainland are known as Blackburn Bay. Learn more below about the properties and amenities of Casey Key, Florida.

Homes for Sale in Casey Key, Florida

The Casey Key Community & Real Estate

Casey Key can be accessed from the mainland at two points, the North Bridge (Blackburn Point Bridge) located in Osprey and the South Bridge (Albee Road Bridge) in Nokomis. This North Bridge to Casey Key can be reached from Downtown Sarasota in approximately 20 to 30 minutes, making Downtown easily accessible and easily escapable back to the dazzling Casey Key. Casey Key and its homes are known for elegant Floridian architecture, quiet serene atmosphere, and long stretches of peaceful uncrowded beaches.

Most of the homes for sale on Casey Key are large single-family homes. These display a range of evergreen styles including Spanish-revival, Modernist, and beach bungalow. Some of the grandest homes on Casey Key can range upwards of 6,000 square feet in size, and exhibit the best of Florida's modern architectural styles including light maximization, floating spaces, wall-to-wall-to-ceiling windows, open interiors, and large decks or balconies. Many of the homes on Casey Key also feature covered lanai pools, elevated decks, ground-floor parking, and lush gardens.

Where Casey Key narrows in the North, some properties enjoy access and views of both the Gulf of Mexico and the interior Blackburn Bay. While all homes on Casey Key can be regarded as high-end there are many cozy smaller properties like beach cottages and bungalows under 1,000 Sq Ft throughout the island. Private docks and direct beach access are two defining features of the luxury Casey Key real estate market. As such, Casey Key hosts some of the most sought-after properties in South-West Florida.

Natural Recreation on Casey Key

Casey Key is a fantastic location for enjoying Florida's favorite activities, like fishing, boating, kayaking, beachcombing, snorkeling, wildlife spotting, and sunbathing. 

Wildlife in the area includes dolphins, manatees, and various coastal birds.

Other attractions on Casey Key Include

  • Nokomis Public Beach
  • Casey Key Marina at Blackburn Point Swing Bridge
  • Midnight Pass
  • North Jetty Park, which includes a playground and the North Jetty Tap & Grill
  • Various fishing charters and B&Bs

A very popular activity on Casey Key is combing the beach for shells and fossilized shark teeth. 

For commercial conveniences, residents can easily access the towns of Nokomis and Venice for shopping, banking, and more. 


Albert Wooster

Contact us today to find your new home

Get in touch